The Cheapest Caribbean Islands to Visit

Deputy Executive Editor Sarah Schlichter's idea of a perfect trip includes spotting exotic animals, hiking through pristine landscapes, exploring new neighborhoods on foot, and soaking up as much art as she can. She often attempts to recreate recipes from her international travels after she gets home (which has twice resulted in accidental kitchen fires—no humans or animals were harmed).

Sarah joined the SmarterTravel team in 2017 after more than a decade at the helm of IndependentTraveler.com. Sarah's practical travel advice has been featured in dozens of news outlets including the New York Times, the Chicago Tribune, USA Today, Budget Travel, and Peter Greenberg Worldwide Radio. Follow her on Twitter @TravelEditor.

The Handy Item I Always Pack: "A journal. Even years later, reading my notes from a trip can bring back incredibly vivid memories."

Ultimate Bucket List Experience: "Road tripping and hiking through the rugged mountains of Patagonia."

Travel Motto: "'To awaken quite alone in a strange town is one of the pleasantest sensations in the world.'—Freya Stark"

Aisle, Window, or Middle Seat: "Aisle. I get restless on long flights and like to be able to move around without disturbing anyone else."

Email Sarah at [email protected].

See recent posts by Sarah Schlichter

Dreaming of a relaxing beach vacation? The Caribbean offers beautiful scenery without breaking the bank. We gathered data on airfare, hotel rates, and package deals to unearth the cheapest Caribbean islands to visit, along with reasonably priced places to stay on each one.

To qualify for consideration for our cheapest Caribbean islands list, the destination must also be ranked in the top half of the Price of Travel’s index of the cheapest Caribbean islands. This index measures the relative affordability of Caribbean islands by comparing hotel rates and airfare in high season.

These are the nine cheapest Caribbean islands to visit.

Cozumel

This small island off the coast of Mexico’s Yucatan Peninsula is known for its white sand beaches, colorful marine life, and the Mayan ruins of San Gervasio. While you can fly directly to Cozumel from numerous U.S. airports, including Houston, Denver, Chicago, and New York, you can often save hundreds of dollars by flying to Cancún instead and then taking a ferry to Cozumel from nearby Playa del Carmen. The ferry ride takes approximately 45 minutes and costs around $28 for a round-trip ticket.

Flights to Cancún from most major U.S. airports can be found in the $300-$400 range regularly throughout the year, with many fares falling below the $300 mark.

You’ll likely find cheaper hotel nightly rates between August and November. (Note that this falls within Caribbean hurricane season.)

Where to Stay: The Westin Cozumel, a four-star luxury hotel with a prime beachfront location, has all-inclusive rates in ocean-view rooms starting at $280 per person.

Jamaica

Eco-adventurers will find plenty to do in Jamaica, from swimming in waterfalls to zip-lining through the rainforest. Only-in-Jamaica spots to visit include the Bob Marley Museum and the Rastafari Indigenous Village. And, of course, there are plenty of beaches to relax on between excursions.

With three main tourist areas—Montego Bay, Ocho Rios, and Negril—you can price-shop for the best rates for your Caribbean vacation. Again, travel between May and October may offer lower rates because of hurricane season.

Many US hubs, including Atlanta, Charlotte, Miami, New York, and Philadelphia, offer direct flights to Jamaica. Keep an eye out for good deals, as you can often find cheap flights to Jamaica for $300 or less.
Where to Stay: For an affordable adults-only Caribbean escape, check out the Ocean Eden Bay, which offers all-inclusive rates starting at around $319 per night.

Puerto Rico

In Puerto Rico, you can split your vacation between the lush El Yunque Rainforest, the island’s wide sandy beaches, and the vibrant streets of Old San Juan. A boat trip into one of the island’s bioluminescent bays is another must-do.

Fares from major East Coast airports to San Juan are consistently low, with many round-trip options costing less than $200. Fares from departure airports further west remain reasonable, with options below $300. Budget airline Fronteir serves San Juan and often has sales offering tickets for as low as $100 round-trip.

It’s easy to budget for expenses in Puerto Rico, as the local currency is the U.S. dollar. Bonus: You don’t need to pay for a passport to get there. And with a variety of hotel options all over the island, it’s not hard to find one in your price range.

Where to Stay: The four-star Abitta Boutique Hotel is conveniently located across from the ferry terminal and offers rates under $200 per night.

Dominican Republic

The Dominican Republic is probably the cheapest Caribbean island to visit if you’re looking for affordable, all-inclusive deals. You’ll find dozens of packages in Punta Cana on CheapCaribbean.com, with prices as low as $640 per person for air and three nights’ accommodations. Activities in the area include snorkeling, zip-lining, and off-road ATV tours through the jungle.

There are plenty of popular resort areas in the Dominican Republic where you can focus your hotel search, including La Romana, Puerto Plata, and Samana.

Where to Stay: If you prefer to explore the island and skip the all-inclusive, the four-star Dominican Fiesta Hotel has room rates starting at $84 per night.

Curaçao

Colourful houses of downtown Willemstad, Curacao, Netherlands Antilles. — SCStock | Adobe Stock

You can’t go wrong with a visit to the “C” of the ABC Islands, especially during the spring or fall shoulder season, when you’ll find even more savings. And since Curaçao falls outside the hurricane belt, you can book a trip here without worrying too much about the weather. Whether you visit for the numerous festivals or the pleasant beach weather year-round, on a Caribbean visit to Curaçao you’ll fall in love with the local food trucks, colorful Dutch architecture, unparalleled snorkel spots, and secret beaches.

With nonstop flight options from major U.S. cities like Newark, New York’s JFK, and Miami, Curaçao is highly accessible from the East Coast.

Where to stay: The island has plenty of hotel inventory with competitive nightly rates. Check out ACOYA Curaçao Resort, Villas, & Spa in downtown Willemstad, which starts around $114 per night.

Or try The Rif at Mangrove Beach, which has all-inclusive rates for under $300 per night.

Martinique

This French overseas region attracts a sophisticated crowd, particularly travelers from Canada and Europe looking for a cosmopolitan Caribbean experience.

If you’re not the type of traveler who likes to lounge on the beach for your whole vacation, Martinique is the right island for you, as the mountainous landscape offers plenty of hiking opportunities. Culinary enthusiasts will delight in the island’s gastronomic scene, which fuses French techniques with Caribbean flavors and local ingredients.

The island’s international appeal is evident in its air connections, with direct flights from North American cities like Miami, Montreal, and Toronto, as well as European hubs such as Paris, Frankfurt, and Rome.

If you’re willing to be flexible with your dates, you can often find flights from the US for around $400-$500.
Where to stay: There are plenty of small, rustic bed and breakfasts in Martinique that offer rooms for under $100 per night, but if you’re looking for a more luxurious experience, Hotel Diamant Les Bains is a highly-rated four-star hotel with affordable nightly rates of around $170.

Grenada

Grenada’s nickname, “The Spice Island,” is well-earned. The air is perfumed with the subtle aroma of nutmeg, a testament to the island’s rich agricultural heritage. But spices are just the beginning—Grenada’s appeal lies in its unspoiled nature, secluded beaches, and relaxed pace.

Accommodations range from comfortable mid-range resorts to exclusive luxury retreats catering to various budgets and preferences. You can find direct flights to Grenada from Miami, New York City, and Charlotte, but expect to pay a premium for the convenience. If you’re willing to have a layover, you can find great airfare deals for as low as $300.

Where to stay: The Radisson Grenada overlooks the world-famous Grand Anse Beach and has two beautiful outdoor swimming pools. You can find rooms at this four-star resort for under $200 per night.

Barbados

ROSSEAU, DOMINICA - April 7, 2011 The Commonwealth of Dominica, is an Island country in the West Indies which has become a popular cruise ship destination — dbvirago | Adobe Stock

JetBlue and American Airlines have recently expanded their service to Barbados to meet increased travel demand, which has helped drive down the airfare prices to this eastern Caribbean gem. If you’re willing to travel in the off-season, you can find flights for as low as $200 round-trip.

The island draws scuba divers and snorkelers because of its reputation as a great diving destination. But Barbados is far more than just its stunning coastline. While the beaches rightfully claim fame with their powdery sands and crystal-clear waters, the island is also home to Bridgetown, a Unesco World Heritage-listed capital city.

Where to stay: There’s a wide range of accommodations in Barbados, where you’ll find $104 per night properties right next door to $2,000 per night resorts. Crystal Cove occupies an excellent middle ground, with all-inclusive rates for as low as $350 per night.

Antigua

Known for its breathtaking beauty, Antigua boasts an impressive 365 beaches—one for every day of the year. These pristine stretches of sand, lapped by crystal-clear turquoise waters, range from secluded coves to lively party beaches.

Surprisingly affordable flights make Antigua one of the more budget-friendly options among the smaller Caribbean islands. If you want to spend those airfare savings on a hotel, there are plenty of splurge-worthy luxury resorts that will cater to your every whim and desire. However, you can stick to a budget here as well, with four-star resorts available for as low as $99 per night.

Where to stay: If you’re in the mood for a romantic all-inclusive vacation, Cocos Hotel is an adults-only resort that caters to couples. Rates start at around $450 per night.

For a cheaper hotel option, the Antigua Yacht Club Marina & Resort has rooms for as low as $99 per night.

Tips for Saving Money on Caribbean Trips

No matter which Caribbean island paradise you choose, following a few simple tips can help you save money on your vacation.

Be flexible with your dates—most airlines do not operate daily flights to the Caribbean, so you can find better schedules and deals by being open to traveling on any day of the week
Travel during the Caribbean’s off-season, June through November. However, be aware that this is hurricane season, and purchase travel insurance to protect your trip.
Sign up for airfare alerts on our sister site, Airfarewatchdog, which will let you know when ticket prices fall.
Search for flight and package deals at all-inclusive resorts. Cheap Caribbean, JetBlue Vacations, and Travelzoo are all good places to look.
Sign up for emails from resorts you’re interested in, as they often send out promotions or sales.

Editor’s note: This story was originally published in 2019. It has been updated to reflect the most current information. Sarah Schlichter contributed to this story.

You Might Also Like:

• 8 Places You Didn’t Know You Could Afford
• The Best Places to Retire in 2025
• The 6 Best Lightweight Waterproof Hiking Boots for Travel
• What to Pack for the Caribbean: 35 Essentials
• Snowcat Tacos and 4 Other Amazing Ski Resort Amenities

We hand-pick everything we recommend and select items through testing and reviews. Some products are sent to us free of charge with no incentive to offer a favorable review. We offer our unbiased opinions and do not accept compensation to review products. All items are in stock and prices are accurate at the time of publication. If you buy something through our links, we may earn a commission.