Skip navigation

Cheap Airfare, Vacation Deals, Car Rental, and Discount Travel - SmarterTravel.com
User's Avatar
My SmarterTravel

Tight Budget? Save Big With Vacation Rentals

by Sarah Pascarella, SmarterTravel.com Staff - March 9, 2009
Cottage RentalIf your idea of a vacation consists of staying in a private cottage on an island, then look no further than Nantucket. This New England island offers the best of both worlds with its quaint downtown area filled with shops and fine dining, and miles of white, sandy beaches. Cottages typically rent by the week, and can start at about $750. This can be the perfect getaway for those who want to escape from it all, and be completely self-sufficient.  (Photo: iStockphoto)

If you've never stayed at a vacation rental before, this may be the year to try one. Economical, spacious, and often in stellar locations, vacation rentals can be an ideal money-saving option for all types of travelers. In these tough economic times, finding a great property that matches your taste and budget can be only a few clicks away.

"Most people always save when going the vacation rental route, especially in a group of four or more," says TJ Mahony, CEO and co-founder of SmarterTravel sister site FlipKey.com. "And they can be some of the nicest accommodations around."

Advertisement

What Exactly is a Vacation Rental?

A vacation rental is a single property that typically is rented by a traveler (you) from the owner. Rentals range from beachside homes to mountain cabins to city apartments. Accommodations can be booked from owners directly, property managers, or a third-party supplier (such as Rentalo or VacationRoost).

Who Should Choose a Vacation Rental?

While I've long been a fan of vacation rentals and think every type of traveler should give them a try, certain demographics can really benefit.

  • Families: Whether it's a single family or an extended crew, a vacation rental can be an economical and value-packed choice for relatives traveling together. Take, for example, this Orlando vacation rental property listed on Vacation Rentals by Owner (VRBO). The four-bedroom, three-bath home, about 10 miles from DisneyWorld, costs $1,050 per week in summer, and features a fully equipped kitchen, a washer and dryer, a pool and a hot tub, and a deck and patio, plus a television in every room. In a scenario of two families of four traveling together, the cost per adult would be $263, or approximately $38 per night. Not bad for renting a whole house with all the amenities included. If money is tight, the savings afforded by a vacation rental might make the difference between getting away this year or not. "For families, once they find out about vacation rentals, they might just be able to say look, we can do this," says Kathy Jones, Florida representative for WeNeedaVacation.com.
  • Girlfriends: There's been a lot of promotions for girlfriends' getaways in recent years that, once deconstructed, don't actually offer a good value. A vacation rental is a great option for groups of friends hoping to save some money, for the same reasons as families. Divided among friends, you'll often find a great bargain with plenty of extras.
  • Students: Students tend to travel in packs and visit popular beach destinations, where rentals abound. If you choose a property in an area where the dollar is strong, such as Mexico or Central and South America, you'll get an even better bang for your buck.
  • Solo Travelers: Yes, rentals are economical when split among several people. But if you're a solo traveler, you can also get a good deal. SmarterTravel Associate Editor Kate Hamman recently booked a Montreal apartment all for herself, and paid less than she would have at hotels in her neighborhood. If you're planning a solo vacation, don't count out a rental for your trip—you may be pleasantly surprised at what you find.

Why Book One Now?

If you're a penny-pinching traveler, the rewards are obvious. You'll get a cheaper per-night price than many area hotels, a much roomier space, and the benefit of kitchen facilities to cook your own meals (offering significant savings over pricey restaurants). In many cases, the location can't be beat: You can rent waterfront properties in popular beach or lake destinations, in or near ski areas, or in desirable city neighborhoods.

As for when to book—that will depend on your destination. To ensure the best availability, particularly for popular destinations and peak travel times (holidays, school vacations, etc.), it's always recommended to book a few months before your trip. If you know your destination is really in demand (e.g., Orlando or Cape Cod in summer; Aspen, Florida beaches, or the Caribbean in winter), it's not unreasonable to book a year in advance. And while it's not always the best strategy, some properties do offer deals if there's last-minute availability. If you're working with an individual property owner, you can always inquire if there are any available discounts; third-party suppliers often post the latest deals right on their websites.

Where Do You Find Good Vacation Rentals?

Rather than sift through the (literally) millions of vacation rental results available online, reputable providers such as HomeAway and its affiliated brands (CyberRentals.com, VacationRentals.com, VRBO, and several others), Vacation Rentals Web Directory, and Zonder, among others, are tried-and-true places to start your research. Columnist Ed Perkins also weighs in on his preferred vacation rental sites that are worth a look. To see what our readers have recommended, check out our recent tip on new vacation rental websites—and don't hesitate to tell us about your own favorites.

What Should You Watch Out For?

Whether you're new to vacation rentals or an old pro, there are always a few precautions you should take before your trip.

Whether you're booking with an individual or a property management company, get a well-written rental agreement in place before any money changes hands, says Mahony. The contract should "stipulate the terms and economics and what each party is responsible for ... If there's no agreement in place, don't pay a deposit, because without one there's no itemization on how to get your money back."

With the economic recession, there has also been concern about vacation homes going into foreclosure. If you're concerned about this possibility, make sure to request a clause specifically about foreclosure to be written into the rental agreement so you can recoup any lost deposits or payments.

You also want to make sure to investigate travel insurance options to cover any deposits and pre-trip expenditures. A basic trip cancelation/interruption plan can cover most problems. Additionally, Travel Guard offers insurance specifically for financial default (e.g., foreclosure) on vacation rentals, with one caveat. "[The traveler] must purchase insurance within 15 days of putting down the initial payment on the property to be covered for financial default," says Dan McGinnity, vice president, Travel Guard. If you act within this window, you should be covered.

Regardless of what insurance provider you choose, be sure to review all policy terms thoroughly to make sure you're purchasing the right type of coverage for your vacation.

If possible, pay with a credit card, suggests Jones. "You have the right to protest the charge if denied access [to the home]."

For additional peace of mind, rent with professional companies, rather than individual property owners. "Find a property manager or rental agency and go to someone who has a good inventory," says Jones.

"I was in the office with a [vacation property] manager," says Lee Hughes, vice president, sales division, CSA Travel Protection. "The phone rang—a customer had come back from grocery shopping and the vacation rental house had been locked up and the locks had been changed. The manager jumped in the car, picked those folks up, took them to his house, went to the bank, got that straightened out, got a sheriff to come out. He then moved the couple to a much nicer house and refunded their money for the entire week. This particular [manager] had been in business a long time and ... knew to deal with the [bad] situation and make it a positive. That's the way professionals treat something like this. Managers do the best they can to make sure bad situations don't happen."

Regardless of whether you're dealing with a company or an individual owner, a clearly written rental agreement and appropriate insurance coverage can help protect your travel investment.

Are You a Fan of Vacation Rentals? Share Your Expertise!

If you're looking to get more for your money—more space, amenities, and value—consider a vacation rental this year. Have a recommendation we haven't covered here? Any suggestions for must-have items in the rental contract, or things to be careful about? Share your tips by submitting a comment below!

 
 
Comments: (1)
 
Tiffanyla's Avatar
Tiffanyla wrote:
This comment has been marked as abusive and removed.
 

Archived Comments:

  • Bashar - March 9, 2009

    I've tried it for my trip to Cardiff, got my apartment from A Space in the City at Century Wharf www.aspaceinthecity.co.uk/ . Was pretty good, wide, and money saving, with security, and right in the middle of Cardiff Bay. Kitchen and appliances. Only bad thing was there internet service, too slow. They do some quick cleaning once a week.

  • Freesp - March 9, 2009

    I have used VRBO twice and both times was pleased. I traveled solo to Florida and had a nice studio condo directly on the beach and also used VRBO in Puerto Rico for another condo right on the beach. No problems at all, nice clean units. Planning my next trip and wouldn't go any other way now!!

  • Hansen@ResorTime - March 9, 2009

    Great article on the benefits of vacation rentals. The resources you listed are great for people who want to rent a week from an individual renting out their timeshare but you could also rent condos/vacation rentals by the night at http://www.ResorTime.com. Instead of dealing with an individual ResorTime.com gathers the inventory for over 250 properties and you rent from them by the night at very low rates. The service is even more valuable if you are a timeshare owner at one of their affiliated properties because you get extremely discounted rates and all of their properties.

  • Thomas - March 9, 2009

    As a Holiday Home Owner I found this an interesting read, with some sound advice for people seeking to rent a vacation home. Indeed there are some very disturbing stories out there about dodgy holiday home owners. Similarly, however, there are also some horror stories associated with renting through supposed professional companies and management agencies. The article illustrates a good example of where a vacation property manager saved the day. But a number of my guests have reported not being so lucky on occasion. Sadly the article ignores the obvious plus points associated with booking a holiday home through the owner directly (not least you can be assured of a much more personal service), and the things people can do to check out the property they would like to rent for peace of mind (e.g. phone the owner, speak to them, ask questions, etc.). The article is spot on at least one point - if you have never tried vacation rentals, now is certainly the time to give it a go. Thomas Basse Copette France

  • Mherman - March 9, 2009

    Be sure to ask how security deposits are handled. There are typically several options: credit card number on file, credit card hold charge or damage waiver. Having anywhere from several hundred to several thousand dollars worth of your money tied up in a credit card hold can limit your enjoyment while on your vacation and sometimes for several weeks afterward. Many professional vacation rental management companies offer a damage waiver for a small fee that insures both you and them against accidental damage while allowing your fun-money to remain accessible.

  • miveep - March 9, 2009

    I have rented thru VRBO in Tobago, Costa Rica, Eleuthera, Los Cabos, Belize. I have been only disappointed once and it wasn't the property, it was the owner who was going thru a divorce and tried to embroil us in it. Do your research, have a great and inexpensive time.

  • Steve - March 10, 2009

    A true professional manager would not embroil you in a divorce. Don't take chances. Go with a pro.

  • Suzy Hall - March 10, 2009

    Great article. Thank you. As the owner of mountain-home.com, a vacation rental management company in Montana, I'd like to mention one other benefit of using a management service with a variety of properties. Management companies typically have a spectrum of properties in their portfolio, and a good service will query prospective guests about what they're dreaming of, and about their group's specific requirements, then recommend the property or properties that best fit their group. It's not uncommon for us to steer guests away from a home that they are initially interested in, to one that we're certain will suit them better. And we find that, almost universally, our guests are extremely pleased with the property we recommend. And yes, the bottom line for the vacationer is to do your homework. Be sure to ask whether cleaning is complimentary or an additional fee, and whether you have to put down a security deposit or if a deposit waiver is available (for a fee or included).

  • celeste1938 - March 10, 2009

    Aloha! My husband and I are retired professionals. I love to travel - however he is a "stay at home and putz around the garden" kind of guy. We live in a single family large five bedroom with pool and hot tub located in the center of Oahu - (the main island in Hawaii., (Honolulu (&Waikiki) is 30 - 40 minutes - as is the famous North shore surfing beach. My question is if anyone would be interested in renting while "hubby" iis living in one bedroom. I would either exchange or rent with my daughter and grandchildren - elsewhere! Celeste in Hawaii

  • Sarah Pascarella, SmarterTravel - March 10, 2009

    There have been a lot of deals for vacation rentals lately, so check out our latest blog with a roundup of current offerings: http://www.smartertravel.com/blogs/today-in-travel/vacation-rentals-on-sale-if-you-know-where-to-look.html?id=2851952 Also let me know where you like to look for vacation rental deals!

  • Liz - March 12, 2009

    I am tempted with a vacation rental but when I check availability & see that there is availability from today onward to the end of the year, I wonder if this is a red flag. One place I checked on I was able to contact the owner directly, through email, & wonder if this is appropriate. Thanks for any info.

  • Sarah Pascarella, SmarterTravel - March 12, 2009

    Hi Liz, An open availability calendar need not be a red flag. Given the recession, it may simply be a sign of the times. Go ahead and contact the owner directly through email to learn more about the property, and feel free to ask a lot of questions--that's what the owners are there for! If you have any hesitation, you're under no obligation to book. Doing a bit more research into other properties in your destination, and getting in touch with several other property owners may also give you additional peace of mind.

  • Carolina Mornings - March 12, 2009

    Whether one uses a management company or goes directly with a home owner, a vacation rental is the best value for the money. The biggest advantage for dealing with a home owner is money. It is usually less expensive when you do not use a management company. The benefits of using a good company has been identified in some of the comments above: better selection of homes, better matching personal needs to the vacation rental, professionally managed and cleaned and ability to relocate guests if the property is unsuitable. In our state of North Carolina, the vacation rental management companies are regulated by the NC Vacation Renters Act and must maintain the highest standards. This ensures renters fair and honest treatment. Individual owners are not held to the same standards, nor do they adhere to the same policies as the state laws.

  • glenna - March 12, 2009

    Looking for a place for 4 families around Christmas with things for kids 4-9 to do-not too expensive

  • Sandra Kennedy - March 19, 2009

    I have used VRBO for reasonable and wonderful rentals in Ashland, Oregon and Buenos Aires. In September, I will be using Homeaway for an apartment in Lisbon for a week. Best way to travel, in my opinion.

  • VacationMamma - March 19, 2009

    Thank you for a well balanced article on vacation rentals. I started in this business as a vacationer with a young family who was no longer comfortable in B&B's or in hotels when we traveled together. Discovering vacation rentals (summer cottages where I grew up) opened the world to us. I just returned from one in Athens Greece (www.athenspenthouses.com - Acropolis View Beta) for business/pleasure instead of the Hilton. No longer are these just for ourselves though. In 1999 I bought my first vacation home and immediately turned to vacation rentals to help make our retirement dream come true. By 2006 I had people here in CA asking me to manage their places for them and voila - I went from "rent by owner" to "professional property manager" nearly overnight (after earning a RE License). I now run BETTER Vacation Rentals www.bettervacationrentals.com and can personally attest that not all vacation rentals, owners, or managers are created equal. Do your homework, ask questions, use a credit card or PayPal, and enjoy a much better way to travel - cheaper, more spacious, more intimate, more private. Oh - and when I'm looking for a vacation rental - I both google the a location and "vacation rentals" and I go to vrconnection.com and now tripadvisor.com and vrbo.com (though their interface is just awful). If I want to do a trade (if you are an owner) I go to itravex.com - but you have to be a vrbo customer to do so. Enjoy.

  • santapaws - March 24, 2009

    BEWARE! Apt rentals in Paris from American Mgmt Co. Never Again, the pictures do not began to describe the filthy dirty, dusty and musty unit that you are about to enter and live for a week. The Mgmt co has no idea of the condition of the unit or the condition and repairs that are needed on this side on the pond. there is no site represenative or quality control necessary for owner to comply with, just take the money and have no concience about what the tourists will receive.Back to a hotel with better location, quality control and some one who is empowered to take care of problems.

  • Kris - March 30, 2009

    Another great place I've used to find professionally managed vacation rentals is ClearStay.com. They have a great supply of managed homes and many are bookable online in real-time.

  • Travelingtolisbon - October 12, 2009

    It is a very nice and good post. Keep up the good work.

ALERT!
Your pop-up blocker security
setting is too high.



To view this page and still use your pop-up blocker, please make the following adjustment to Internet Explorer.

- Click on "Tools"
- Click on "Pop-up Blocker"
- Click on "Always Allow Pop-ups from This Site..."
- Try the link again

If you are not using Internet Explorer or are still having issues, please email feedback@smartertravel.com with details

Hotels

COMPARE PRICES
Air Departure Date Calendar
Air Return Date Calendar
NEWSLETTER SIGN UP
Get the early word on the latest travel deals of the day picked by our editors. Sign up for our free Deal Alert newsletter.

email address:

DESTINATIONS