Author: Lilyan Wolberg
Date of Trip: August 2007
I had booked a 2 night stay at a hotel in Manhattan and several days prior to my trip, I decided I wanted to get into New York City earlier. I was not able to book the same hotel at the same price so I located another one close by. I booked a 2 night stay at the Carter Hotel on 43rd Street. It was a perfect location for me so I felt pretty good about being able to get the reservation.
When I arrived at the Carter, I noticed that there were 5 or six steps to get into the lobby…no elevator or ramp for me with a walker. There also was no bellhop or any person to assist with the luggage. I managed the steps with the help of a friend and proceeded to the desk. I checked in and was asked to pay one dollar for a key to my room. I had never had this request at any hotel I ever stayed at. OK…I paid the dollar and was given the key to my room. I went up (thank goodness there was an elevator in the lobby since I was on the 19th floor!!) and found my room…… The room was small…this I could live with but the curtains on the windows were sheets…the bathroom was so small you couldn’t open the door all the way because it would hit the “john.”..I thought I would manage so I didn’t complain.
When I found there was no lamp in the room, only an overhead ceiling fixture, I decided to call for room service. I dialed the number and it rang…and rang…and rang…and no one picked up the phone. As I went down to the desk I met a young man who was furious because he also could not reach anyone on the phone. At the desk I asked for help in getting a lamp…also a chair since there was none in the room…and help in getting the air conditioning started. The TV in the room played only 3 or 4 channels clearly…the rest were blurred or not clear enough to view…. and for the 2 day stay in that hotel, my linen and towels were never changed!!!
I would advise anyone who plans on staying at the Carter Hotel to think twice before booking. My next stop was 3 streets away…same location..West 46th Street between B’way and 8th Ave. at the Paramount Hotel, which was a palace by comparison. It really was a very nice hotel, with a staff that was courteous, helpful and very pleasant. The room was what a hotel room should be like. This hotel I would highly recommend. Happy traveling….
We hand-pick everything we recommend and select items through testing and reviews. Some products are sent to us free of charge with no incentive to offer a favorable review. We offer our unbiased opinions and do not accept compensation to review products. All items are in stock and prices are accurate at the time of publication. If you buy something through our links, we may earn a commission.