Girls' getaways debunked

by , SmarterTravel Staff
Girlfriends on couch (Photo: Index Open)
Editor's Note: This story was originally published on September 10, 2007. To see the most recent SmarterTravel articles on related topics, please click on any of the following links: Hilton, Omni Hotels, Sarah Pascarella, weekend getaways, women's travel.

Every autumn, I take a long-weekend trip with three girlfriends from college. Throughout the years, we've visited a host of cities along the East Coast, from Boston to Orlando. Next year, for our 30th birthdays, we hope to go overseas. As budget travelers, we tend to plan our trips on the cheap, preferring low-cost airlines, vacation-rental apartments, and economy rental cars.

My friends and I have been ahead of the curve: As Weekend Getaways editor here at SmarterTravel.com, I've noticed more and more marketers putting together pre-planned "girls' getaways," with themes ranging from spa retreats to adventure outings. The hook varies little between providers: indulge, reconnect with female friends and family members, leave the guys at home.

Advertisement

That indulgence, however, sometimes is an outright marketing ploy to get your travel dollars, and many times, these getaways are ridiculously overpriced. The problem is often threefold:

  • Girlfriends' getaways are usually based on a per-person charge, not a per-room charge (unlike most couples' getaways). Structured in this way, two girlfriends traveling together often pay twice as much as a couple does.
  • Many girls' getaway packages contain items similar to couples' getaways (massages, spa treatments, dinners, desserts), but at higher rates.
  • Many of the "specials" included in these packages are, frankly, pretty lackluster. Oftentimes you can put together a similar (or better) experience on your own for less.

Take a look at the following to see what I mean:

The Arsenic & Old Lace Bed and Breakfast Inn in Eureka Springs, Arkansas, offers both romance and girlfriend getaway packages. Both contain similar amenities, but the pricing differs a bit. Here's the breakdown:

Girlfriend getaway:

  • Two nights' accommodations
  • A luxurious robe
  • One-hour facial
  • $30 dinner voucher
  • Souvenir coffee mug

Cost per person: $445 for weekends, October weekdays, and holidays.

Romantic getaway:

  • Two nights' accommodations
  • Bottle of champagne or sparkling cider
  • Two champagne flutes
  • One hour massage for two
  • $65 dinner voucher

Cost per double occupancy: $589 for weekends, October weekdays, and holidays (or $295 per person).

In this case, girlfriends get charged about $150 more than couples for similar or (when you factor in the dinner voucher) lesser amenities. If you're traveling with multiples of two, you might want to consider the romance package—you'll get comparable services for less money.

In another instance of overcharging, consider the Hilton Boston Financial District's Girls Night Out package. Starting at $335 per night per room (double or single occupancy), it includes accommodations, a snack basket with pretzels and cookies, martinis at the hotel bar, a breakfast buffet admission per person, and a late checkout.

When I called for a price quote, autumn weekends came in at $406 per night for the package versus $311 per night for just a room. The package essentially costs $95 more for snacks, breakfast, and a few martinis. You and your girlfriends will get a better deal by booking just a room, then hitting the local convenience store for your snacks, a diner for your breakfast, and a corner bar for drinks.

Meanwhile, Omni Hotels has a Get Your Glam On package for girlfriends at participating hotels across North America. Packages include accommodations, nightly turndown service, a "chick flick" DVD, two candles, a bottle of wine and chocolate-covered strawberries, and lip gloss.

When I checked the glam package prices against standard room rates at several Omni hotels, I found the package typically cost $50 to $60 more than a regular room rate. $50 or $60 extra for wine, lip gloss, and a DVD? I think you could put this together on your own for less.

For comparison, sample per-night prices are:

  • Omni Dallas Hotel at Park West: $99 lowest per-night rate, $159 Get Your Glam On rate. Package costs $60 more.
  • Omni Los Angeles at California Plaza: $169 lowest per-night rate, $219 Get Your Glam On rate. Package costs $50 more.
  • Omni Orlando Resort at ChampionsGate: $199 lowest per-night rate, $254 Get Your Glam On rate. Package costs $55 more.
  • Omni Chicago Hotel: $329 lowest per-night rate, $384 Get Your Glam On rate. Package costs $55 more.
  • Omni Berkshire Place: $359 lowest per-night rate, $415 Get Your Glam On rate. Package costs $56 more.
12Next
Read comments or add your own insight!
Please enable JavaScript to properly view and use this web site.