Skip navigation

Cheap Airfare, Vacation Deals, Car Rental, and Discount Travel - SmarterTravel.com
My SmarterTravel

Freedom is better than Fantasy

Posted by Erica Silverstein, SmarterTravel.com Staff
Piano bar on the Carnival Freedom (Photo:Carnival)
Editor's Note: This story was originally published on January 22, 2008. To see the most recent SmarterTravel articles on related topics, please click on any of the following links: Carnival, cruise, cruise cabin, Erica Silverstein, mainstream ship, onboard cruise amenity, Ship to Shore.

You can debate the philosophical issues implicit in my blog headline, but I'm talking about Carnival ships. A while back, I sailed on the Fantasy, one of Carnival's older ships. Today, I'm on the Carnival Freedom, the newest ship in the fleet, and the improvements are noticeable.

Number one improvement: the food. I've twice found satisfying lunches at the pool-deck buffet, which is tough for a vegetarian. The salad bar offered an array of veggies, beans, and pasta salads, and the pizzeria served slices fresh from the oven. My Indian dinner last night tasted like actual Indian food rather than some sad vegetables with spices on them. I also was introduced to Carnival's famous chocolate melting cake. It very nearly brought this chocoholic to tears, and I understand why the dish is so popular it's on the menu every single night.

Advertisement

Another improvement is the public areas. Joe Farcus' decor is often blindingly over the top and a little too theme-like for my taste. However, many of the bars and lounges are downright fun, such as the keyboard themed piano bar and the Monticello library, which looks like it's been lifted straight out of the White House. The giant LED screen on the pool deck was the perfect place to watch the Patriots beat the Chargers, and this ship's waterslide looks bigger and better than its predecessors.

As always, Carnival does a nice job with its cabins. My balcony stateroom has more storage space than two gals can fill up, and neither the bathroom nor the shower is claustrophobic. The beds are super-comfortable, which could be considered a negative because I did not want to get up this morning and explore the rest of the ship.

My one complaint so far would be the timing of the activities. All of the games or classes I wanted to attend today took place at the same time in the afternoon or during my dinner seating. I'd like to see Carnival space out the events, with more interesting activities in the pre-lunch hours.

Tomorrow I'll let you know how Carnival's shore excursion program holds up.

More blog entries

Guidelines: We love hearing from you, especially when your posts are thoughtful, polite, concise and unique. However, we do reserve the right to remove posts that are written in less than a "community spirit". Please see the full list of unacceptable comment types here.
Comments FAQ's

ALERT!
Your pop-up blocker security
setting is too high.



To view this page and still use your pop-up blocker, please make the following adjustment to Internet Explorer.

- Click on "Tools"
- Click on "Pop-up Blocker"
- Click on "Always Allow Pop-ups from This Site..."
- Try the link again

If you are not using Internet Explorer or are still having issues, please email feedback@smartertravel.com with details

Hotels

COMPARE PRICES
NEWSLETTER SIGN UP
Get the early word on the latest cruise deals picked by our editors twice every month by signing up for our free Cruise News newsletter.

email address:

DESTINATIONS