Three Ways to Snag a First-Class Seat

On Frequent Flyer Miles
images/photos/columnists/timwinship.gif
Dining in first class (Photo: Stewart Cohen/Index Open)
Editor's Note: This story was originally published on March 6, 2007. To see the most recent SmarterTravel articles on related topics, please click on any of the following links: frequent flyer, mileage redemption, On Frequent Flyer Miles, Tim Winship, upgrade.

There has never been a better time to fly first class—or a worse time. Planes are packed, filled on average to 80 percent of capacity, which means that comfort is in short supply.

Remember when the claustrophobia of coach was mitigated somewhat by the ready availability of empty middle seats? In the current era, a vacant middle seat is the exception rather than the rule. Comfort levels have eroded accordingly.

Advertisement

Against that cramped, dreary backdrop, a comfy seat, with plenty of elbow and leg room, has never been more welcome. Those roomy seats can only be found in the first-class cabin (or in business class, in those few cases where it's offered on domestic flights).

Even as the allure of first class has heightened, the airlines have cut back on the number of first-class seats in their desperate attempts to align capacity with consumer demand. Wide-bodies have been replaced by single-aisle aircraft, and narrow-bodies have given way to regional jets. With each such downgrade, the number of first-class seats has decreased, both in absolute terms and as a percentage of the airlines' overall seats.

How can comfort-seekers snag one of those big seats without taking out a second mortgage to finance the expenditure? Generally speaking, there are three ways to get to the front of the plane.

Just pay cash

The old-fashioned approach is simply to buy a first-class ticket. With prices ranging from over $1,000 to more than $4,500 for a coast-to-coast round-trip, most consumers can't justify the expenditure. Indeed, it's tough to rationalize spending between three and 10 times more for first class than for coach, just for a few fleeting hours of extra comfort and a better meal.

This outlook explains why so few travelers purchase these high-priced tickets. While the airlines refuse to disclose the breakdown between full-revenue passengers and those who have upgraded to first class, my unscientific surveys suggest that perhaps 10 percent of those sitting up front paid the full published fare for the privilege.

Those flying across the Atlantic to Europe can consider another option: business-class-only carriers such as Eos (flying between New York and London Stansted), Maxjet (also serving Stansted from several U.S. airports), and PrivatAir (serving Munich and Dusseldorf from Newark and Chicago). These airlines have only one class of service, comparable to the business- or first-class accommodations of traditional airlines. The good news for flyers paying their own way is ticket prices on these carriers are closer to business class than to first, making flights a relative bargain.

The mileage upgrade

A more affordable route to first class is to combine cash and miles by purchasing a coach ticket and redeeming frequent flyer miles to upgrade to first.

Using fares available for flights between Los Angeles and New York as an example, I found that advance-purchase coach tickets cost between $228 and $688, with the majority clustering around the $350 mark. In most programs, an upgrade from a discounted coach ticket to first class (or to business, if it's a three-cabin jet) costs 10,000 to 15,000 miles each way, or 20,000 to 30,000 miles round-trip.

Is it worth it? I don't have a definitive answer, but there are several ways to think about the issue.

When you upgrade with miles, you're essentially spending those miles in exchange for a seat that would normally cost from $400 to $4,000 more than was actually paid. Redeeming 20,000 miles for an upgrade to a seat worth $4,000 more than the purchased coach seat would yield a per-mile value of 20 cents each. Since the current rough-and-ready valuation of a frequent flyer mile is between one and two cents, the upgrade scenario can look awfully attractive. Bear in mind that that calculation assumes that the price of a first-class ticket fairly reflects its value. Many consumers are skeptical that a first-class seat is worth 10 times more than its coach counterpart.

Read comments or add your own insight!
Please enable JavaScript to properly view and use this web site.