Skip navigation

Cheap Airfare, Vacation Deals, Car Rental, and Discount Travel - SmarterTravel.com
My SmarterTravel

Lesson Not Learned: United Loses Musician's Bag

Posted on November 2, 2009 at 4:47 pm ET by Carl Unger, SmarterTravel.com Staff
Photo: United Airlines


You remember "United Breaks Guitars," right? Of course you do. The song, written as a desperate attempt to strike back at the airline, became a YouTube sensation and publicity nightmare (or boon, depending on whether or not you think all publicity is good publicity) for United, and propelled musician Dave Carroll to worldwide notoriety both as a singer and burgeoning passenger-rights speaker.

But all that fame and attention apparently doesn't mean Carroll's bags won't get lost, even when flying the very airline he mocked in his music. That's right, United lost Dave Carroll's bag last week, as he was flying from Regina, Saskatchewan, to Denver to give a speech about—you guessed it—airline customer service. Yes, this story is thick with irony.

Advertisement

"The only direct flight to Denver was with United," Carroll said. "So I flew United and my bag got lost." Not only were his bags lost, but they took an absolutely bizarre route. His bags traveled first to Calgary, and then to Dallas-Ft. Worth, before arriving in Denver several days after he did.

"I guess the smart thing to do would be to avoid United," Carroll said. The airline said it would send him a $150 voucher, but as of late last week it hadn't arrived.

United spokeswoman Robin Urbanski, who has already had her hands full with Carroll, said, "We will fully investigate what regretfully happened."

"We are doing everything we can to see it doesn't happen again," United spokesman Charlie Hobart added.

I might suggest not losing so many bags, especially bags that belong to people who've essentially created a niche career out of mocking you … for losing baggage. Just a thought!

Find Related Stories: airfare, Carl Unger, Today in Travel, United

More blog entries

Guidelines: We love hearing from you, especially when your posts are thoughtful, polite, concise and unique. However, we do reserve the right to remove posts that are written in less than a "community spirit". Please see the full list of unacceptable comment types here.
Comments FAQ's

Comments: (9)
 Avatar
Claritus wrote:
Spread it around: THERE'S NOT ENOUGH UNEMPLOYMENT."
 Avatar
ugenefw wrote:
Good old United, two years ago I tried to get a rebate for a Brevement on a flight. Two sets of papers, as requested by their representatives, never did receive anything. Stumbled upon "untied.com" website and after reading how United treated their customers, I stopped talking to India and gave up. Read "untied.com and Dave Carroll will have more material he can use for many lifetimes.ugene.
 Avatar
grw720 wrote:
I travelled with United last week from DC (IAD) to Denver. On arrival my case was damaged: the handle had been completely ripped off. I went to the agents by the carousel and showed them, unhappy but very polite. Their response ? "Oh, United is not responsible for any damage to anything external to the suitace" !! Fortunately, when I went to their office to file a damage report I got someone more intelligent, who was quick to say that of course they would repair it. The staff response from that point forward has been excellent - though the jury is still out until the case gets returned to me properly repaired. But obviously United has a problem with some of its staff. Yes, you have to be an idiot who should never be allowed into contact with customers if you seriously think it's OK to tell a customer that United is entitled to damage his baggage. But presumably the idiot has a manager who could have identified that this staff member would be better employed in a different function. And presumably the idiot's response did unconsciously reveal something about United's attitude to customers and baggage handling. From my experience with United over the years, they deserve most of the criticism they get.
 Avatar
Not to sound too cynical, but my guess is there is a lot more information left out of this article than was included in it. At the very least, it's a good argument for removing all bar codes and labels from previous flights. Unless, of course, you intentionally leave them on, hoping for more material for your routine. Sounds more like the problem isn't United - it's the Canadians, eh.
 Avatar
Maybe he should practice traveling with only carry-on luggage. Jeez...he was only going to Denver to give a speech....how much baggage can that entail!!? trisha* in Boulder....LOL
 Avatar
Aloha7 wrote:
Unfortunately, I think it was done on purpose. I have to agree with Tamlyn111 who said this. After all, it was a direct flight. How difficult is it to tag a bag going from point A to point B?! Perhaps United thinks that bringing their name before the public is good for their bottom line. Name recognition is everything in advertising: they may be betting on the name remaining in the forefront and the criticism being forgotten. Too bad for us the traveler.
 Avatar
I think they did it on purpose... "oh look. Isn't that the @$$hole who mocked us. This will show him" (as the airline rep removes his destination tags... Replacing them with tags to sn alternate destination. He should be thanking the airlines for providing him with additional material for his act (I mean speeches)
 Avatar
Another day, another airline shooting itself in the foot.
 AvatarSmarterTravel Editor
On the other hand, if it wasn't for United, who would have heard of him? His troubles with the broken guitar and now the bags probably introduced him to a much wider audience than he would have had otherwise.
1
ALERT!
Your pop-up blocker security
setting is too high.



To view this page and still use your pop-up blocker, please make the following adjustment to Internet Explorer.

- Click on "Tools"
- Click on "Pop-up Blocker"
- Click on "Always Allow Pop-ups from This Site..."
- Try the link again

If you are not using Internet Explorer or are still having issues, please email feedback@smartertravel.com with details

Hotels

COMPARE PRICES
Air Departure Date Calendar
Air Return Date Calendar
NEWSLETTER SIGN UP
Get the early word on the latest travel deals of the day picked by our editors. Sign up for our free Deal Alert newsletter.

email address:

DESTINATIONS